Flicker Metrics: Percent Flicker, Flicker Index and IEEE 1789
Flicker is easy to see and hard to describe, which is why the industry uses numbers. Two measures dominate. Percent flicker, also called modulation depth, compares the maximum and minimum light output in a cycle. Flicker index compares the area above the average with the total area under the waveform, which captures the shape as well as the depth. Both are calculated from a measured light waveform, and both need the frequency to be meaningful.
The formulas are simple. Percent flicker is the difference between maximum and minimum divided by the sum, expressed as a percentage. A waveform that swings from full to zero has 100 percent flicker; one that varies by ten percent around the average has about ten. Flicker index is the area of the waveform above the mean divided by the total area over one cycle, a number between zero and one that weights a narrow spike differently from a symmetric sine wave.
Frequency decides whether the modulation is visible. Above roughly 100 Hz, direct perception of flicker falls away for most people, but the stroboscopic effect remains: a moving object appears to jump or smear because the light pulses sample the motion. IEEE 1789-2015, a recommended practice, sets thresholds for low-risk and moderate-risk modulation as a function of frequency, with strict limits below 90 Hz and progressively looser limits above 1000 Hz.
The stroboscopic effect has its own metric. CIE TN 006 introduced the stroboscopic effect visibility measure, which weights the frequency components of the light waveform according to human sensitivity to apparent motion. A light source can pass a percent flicker limit and still produce an annoying stroboscopic effect in a workshop with rotating machinery, which is why the metric exists alongside the older measures.
The sources in a dimmable system are known. The 100 or 120 Hz ripple from the rectified mains produces low-frequency modulation. Pulse-width modulation dimming, if the frequency is low, produces deep modulation. Burst mode at light load produces a low-frequency envelope. A well-designed driver suppresses the first and keeps the second above the visible band, which is why flicker performance is often better at full output than at deep dimming.
Measurement requires a photometer with adequate bandwidth and a data logger that captures the waveform, not a lux meter that shows an average. The datasheet should state the flicker metric, the frequency and the test condition, because a percent flicker figure without a frequency says little. For the PV100, the output is filtered to keep low-frequency ripple small, and the dimming interface is analog, which avoids the pulse-width modulation flicker that appears in some digital dimming designs.
The measurement setup matters as much as the metric. A photometer with a slow response averages the waveform and understates the modulation, while a detector with too much bandwidth picks up noise. The detector should be fast enough for the frequency under test and calibrated against a known source, and the reading should include the frequency alongside the depth.
Application decides the acceptable level. An office with static tasks tolerates more modulation than a workshop with rotating machinery, and a broadcast studio tolerates very little. The same driver can be acceptable in one space and unacceptable in another, which is why a specification that names only a percent flicker figure without the application is an incomplete requirement. The metric and the space belong in the same sentence, and the level should be verified in that space rather than only on a bench.
NEC Class 2 Control Circuits: Wiring the 0-10V Pair Correctly
Reading Thermal Derating Curves: Ambient, Load and the Knee Point
Related Article