Lumen Maintenance: L70, L90 and the TM-21 Extrapolation
An LED does not usually fail by going dark; it fails by getting dimmer. The industry therefore defines life as the point at which light output falls to a stated fraction of the initial value. L70 means seventy percent of the initial lumens, L90 means ninety percent, and L50 means half. A specification that says life is fifty thousand hours without naming the criterion is incomplete, because L70 and L90 at the same hours describe very different products.
The measurement comes from LM-80, a test method that runs LED packages or modules at controlled temperatures and currents for a defined period, typically six thousand hours or more. The data are then extrapolated by TM-21, which fits the lumen depreciation curve and projects beyond the test duration with a cap on how far the projection may go, usually six times the measured time. The result is a projection rather than an observation, and the standard is explicit about that.
Temperature and current are the two levers. Higher junction temperature accelerates the depreciation of the phosphor and the package, and higher drive current does the same. The LM-80 report lists the case temperatures and currents tested, and the TM-21 projection applies only within those conditions. A lifetime claim at 55 degrees does not transfer to an installation that runs the modules at 85 degrees, even with the same driver.
The driver influences lumen maintenance through the current it delivers. In a constant-voltage system with resistive limiting, a bus voltage at the top of the tolerance band pushes more current through the LEDs, and the extra current produces extra heat and faster depreciation. The effect is small per fixture but real over a large installation, and it is one reason the output tolerance and the lumen maintenance specification belong in the same review.
Photometric practice separates the initial measurement from the maintained value. LM-79 covers the initial photometric and electrical measurement, typically at a stabilized temperature, and the maintained value comes from LM-80 and TM-21. A project that requires a maintained lumen value should ask for both reports, because a single luminous flux number says nothing about what the installation will deliver in five years.
For the PV100, the relevant discipline is to keep the LED modules within their rated current and temperature, which the 24 volt regulated output supports when the module design matches the bus. The driver does not set the lumen maintenance, but it can undermine it by overdriving the modules, and it can protect it by holding the output steady. A specification that pairs the driver tolerance with the module LM-80 data is the one that predicts the maintained light.
The distinction between lumen maintenance and color maintenance matters too. Phosphor degradation can shift the chromaticity as the module ages, and a product can hold its lumens while drifting in color. Specifiers who care about appearance over time should ask for color maintenance data as well as the L value, because the two are measured and reported separately.
Finally, the numbers assume a constant operating condition. Dimming changes the junction temperature and the current, and both affect the depreciation rate. A system that dims deeply most of the day may age more slowly than the LM-80 test suggests, which is one advantage of a well-controlled dimming strategy and a reason to compare the actual duty cycle with the test condition.
Single-Stage vs Two-Stage Architecture: What the Choice Changes
NEC Class 2 Control Circuits: Wiring the 0-10V Pair Correctly
Related Article